Thrift stores are where we love to find cheap clothes, affordable appliances, and occasionally some of the weirdest objects known to man.

These stores will take anything from anyone, and maybe that… shouldn’t be the case. Or maybe it should – it depends on if you agree with “One man’s trash is another man’s treasure.”

If you’re just a straight up weird person, some of these thrift finds may hit. From butts in a jar to an NSYNC puppet set, here are some of the craziest finds from thrift stores.