Though NFL icon Shannon Sharpe may be able to boast a legendary playing career and a successful podcast, it appears there is one thing the pro athlete doesn’t have — a grasp on the fact that women in their 30s have sex.

On Wednesday, the Denver Broncos alum welcomed model Brittany Renner onto his Club Shay Shay podcast, where he had a shockingly strong reaction to the Basketball Wives LA star opening up about her love life.

“I’ve had sex with 35 guys,” the model admitted during the most recent episode, prompting the athlete to down a shot of liquor.

“Oh Lord,” he continued, taking a swig straight from the bottle before asking if  “anybody else need a shot of this?”

“If I’m judged for having great taste…” she snapped back, trailing off.

She’s right. Who are we to judge her for being able to get it?