20 Comedians People Think Are Overrated

RustyBuckler Published 11/19/2021 in Funny

Comedy is a subjective thing. Everyone has a different taste. Over at r/AskReddit they think these comedians can't even get people to crack a smile.

List View
Player View
Grid View

1.
That guy that does carpool karaoke. -u/guunge

Too bad he doesn't have a good personality to make up for his lack of humor, either.
2.
Lilly Singh I find her relatable but not actually funny. -u/arvinkb

As an Indian, I always felt like punching her whenever I hear her accent and her over-exaggerated mannerisms. It's not a Canadian accent, it's not an Indian accent. It's just annoying
3.
Dan Nainan -u/nebair

He took the idea of “Fake it till you make it” too far. Comedians have more integrity than you realize. They hate people stealing jokes and anyone riding on coattails. Don’t get me wrong, a group of comedians is like a hive of jealous snakes but they don’t like being used or backstabbed.
4.
Amy Schumer -u/_pr0t0n
5.
Carlos Mencia -u/Honky96

Look at me man, I'm not funny, I steal jokes, my dick don't work man, I got to piss in a plastic bag man I got no dick!
6.
Brendan Schaub -u/reptar_runs

Schaub owns the lowest rated comedy special in imdb history and has an entire 45k+follower sub dedicated to making fun of/hating him. It's almost its own extended universe at this point
7.
T.J. Miller. In Silicon Valley, he stole every scene he was in, so when he had a standup special on HBO, I thought it would be hilarious. It was so far from funny I still marvel at how it ever got made. -u/NoOneShallPassHassan
8.
I don't even know why I just hate Jay Leno with a passion. Most of his sh*t just isn't funny. He has an annoying a** laugh. -u/Vanilla_Neko
9.
That guy with the puppets. Jeff dunham. -u/somber_oppossum
10.
Kevin Hart. I get it, he’s short. -u/decentsandwiches
11.
I will never understand the hype around Pete Davidson. Never thought he was funny on SNL. Worked one of his stand up shows. He was high as hell reading jokes off of his phone. -u/count_montecristo
12.
Carrot Top . And even more so when he got jacked. -u/Linsanity998877
13.
Steve Harvey. -u/isthreeinchesenough
14.
Chris D’Elia. Laughs at his own jokes, too. Ugh. -u/kellofkellens
15.
Bill Maher. Even when I agree with him, I just don't think he's clever or funny. -u/the_murder_of_crowe
16.
I love classic Chevy, but his whole career has been one-note. -u/fotomoose
17.
Dane Cook. -goldbrow00
18.
Gabriel Iglesias, I'm not sure why, he’s a great person and some people find him extremely hilarious, but I guess he's not for me. -u/tofimixy
19.
Aziz Ansari. I loved him in Parks and Rec. I didn’t enjoy his set when I saw him live and when I watched his specials. -u/d33jaysturf
20.
Jerry Seinfeld. -u/iwannahitthelotto

1.
That guy that does carpool karaoke. -u/guunge

Too bad he doesn't have a good personality to make up for his lack of humor, either.
2.
Lilly Singh I find her relatable but not actually funny. -u/arvinkb

As an Indian, I always felt like punching her whenever I hear her accent and her over-exaggerated mannerisms. It's not a Canadian accent, it's not an Indian accent. It's just annoying
3.
Dan Nainan -u/nebair

He took the idea of “Fake it till you make it” too far. Comedians have more integrity than you realize. They hate people stealing jokes and anyone riding on coattails. Don’t get me wrong, a group of comedians is like a hive of jealous snakes but they don’t like being used or backstabbed.
4.
Amy Schumer -u/_pr0t0n
5.
Carlos Mencia -u/Honky96

Look at me man, I'm not funny, I steal jokes, my dick don't work man, I got to piss in a plastic bag man I got no dick!
6.
Brendan Schaub -u/reptar_runs

Schaub owns the lowest rated comedy special in imdb history and has an entire 45k+follower sub dedicated to making fun of/hating him. It's almost its own extended universe at this point
7.
T.J. Miller. In Silicon Valley, he stole every scene he was in, so when he had a standup special on HBO, I thought it would be hilarious. It was so far from funny I still marvel at how it ever got made. -u/NoOneShallPassHassan
8.
I don't even know why I just hate Jay Leno with a passion. Most of his sh*t just isn't funny. He has an annoying a** laugh. -u/Vanilla_Neko
9.
That guy with the puppets. Jeff dunham. -u/somber_oppossum
10.
Kevin Hart. I get it, he’s short. -u/decentsandwiches
11.
I will never understand the hype around Pete Davidson. Never thought he was funny on SNL. Worked one of his stand up shows. He was high as hell reading jokes off of his phone. -u/count_montecristo
12.
Carrot Top . And even more so when he got jacked. -u/Linsanity998877
13.
Steve Harvey. -u/isthreeinchesenough
14.
Chris D’Elia. Laughs at his own jokes, too. Ugh. -u/kellofkellens
15.
Bill Maher. Even when I agree with him, I just don't think he's clever or funny. -u/the_murder_of_crowe
16.
I love classic Chevy, but his whole career has been one-note. -u/fotomoose
17.
Dane Cook. -goldbrow00
18.
Gabriel Iglesias, I'm not sure why, he’s a great person and some people find him extremely hilarious, but I guess he's not for me. -u/tofimixy
19.
Aziz Ansari. I loved him in Parks and Rec. I didn’t enjoy his set when I saw him live and when I watched his specials. -u/d33jaysturf
20.
Jerry Seinfeld. -u/iwannahitthelotto

Share This Image

REPLAY GALLERY
20 Comedians People Think Are Overrated

NEXT GALLERY
Taxidermy Wins And Fails

RELATED MEDIA

That guy that does carpool karaoke. -u/guunge

Too bad he doesn't have a good personality to make up for his lack of humor, either.

20/20

1/20

Share
Tweet
Flip
Email
Pin It

Tags: funny lol comedians wow cringe lulz

NEXT GALLERY Taxidermy Wins And Fails

1. That guy that does carpool karaoke. -u/guunge Too bad he doesn't have a good personality to make up for his lack of humor, either.

2. Lilly Singh I find her relatable but not actually funny. -u/arvinkb As an Indian, I always felt like punching her whenever I hear her accent and her over-exaggerated mannerisms. It's not a Canadian accent, it's not an Indian accent. It's just annoying

4. Amy Schumer -u/_pr0t0n

5. Carlos Mencia -u/Honky96 Look at me man, I'm not funny, I steal jokes, my dick don't work man, I got to piss in a plastic bag man I got no dick!

6. Brendan Schaub -u/reptar_runs Schaub owns the lowest rated comedy special in imdb history and has an entire 45k+follower sub dedicated to making fun of/hating him. It's almost its own extended universe at this point

7. T.J. Miller. In Silicon Valley, he stole every scene he was in, so when he had a standup special on HBO, I thought it would be hilarious. It was so far from funny I still marvel at how it ever got made. -u/NoOneShallPassHassan

8. I don't even know why I just hate Jay Leno with a passion. Most of his sh*t just isn't funny. He has an annoying a** laugh. -u/Vanilla_Neko

9. That guy with the puppets. Jeff dunham. -u/somber_oppossum

10. Kevin Hart. I get it, he’s short. -u/decentsandwiches

11. I will never understand the hype around Pete Davidson. Never thought he was funny on SNL. Worked one of his stand up shows. He was high as hell reading jokes off of his phone. -u/count_montecristo

12. Carrot Top . And even more so when he got jacked. -u/Linsanity998877

13. Steve Harvey. -u/isthreeinchesenough

14. Chris D’Elia. Laughs at his own jokes, too. Ugh. -u/kellofkellens

15. Bill Maher. Even when I agree with him, I just don't think he's clever or funny. -u/the_murder_of_crowe

16. I love classic Chevy, but his whole career has been one-note. -u/fotomoose

17. Dane Cook. -goldbrow00

18. Gabriel Iglesias, I'm not sure why, he’s a great person and some people find him extremely hilarious, but I guess he's not for me. -u/tofimixy

19. Aziz Ansari. I loved him in Parks and Rec. I didn’t enjoy his set when I saw him live and when I watched his specials. -u/d33jaysturf

20. Jerry Seinfeld. -u/iwannahitthelotto

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

11.

12.

13.

14.

15.

16.

17.

18.

19.

20.

Share This Image

9 Comments

eBaum's Picks

1.
That guy that does carpool karaoke. -u/guunge

Too bad he doesn't have a good personality to make up for his lack of humor, either.

2.
Lilly Singh I find her relatable but not actually funny. -u/arvinkb

As an Indian, I always felt like punching her whenever I hear her accent and her over-exaggerated mannerisms. It's not a Canadian accent, it's not an Indian accent. It's just annoying

4.
Amy Schumer -u/_pr0t0n

5.
Carlos Mencia -u/Honky96

Look at me man, I'm not funny, I steal jokes, my dick don't work man, I got to piss in a plastic bag man I got no dick!

6.
Brendan Schaub -u/reptar_runs

Schaub owns the lowest rated comedy special in imdb history and has an entire 45k+follower sub dedicated to making fun of/hating him. It's almost its own extended universe at this point

7.
T.J. Miller. In Silicon Valley, he stole every scene he was in, so when he had a standup special on HBO, I thought it would be hilarious. It was so far from funny I still marvel at how it ever got made. -u/NoOneShallPassHassan

8.
I don't even know why I just hate Jay Leno with a passion. Most of his sh*t just isn't funny. He has an annoying a** laugh. -u/Vanilla_Neko

9.
That guy with the puppets. Jeff dunham. -u/somber_oppossum

10.
Kevin Hart. I get it, he’s short. -u/decentsandwiches

11.
I will never understand the hype around Pete Davidson. Never thought he was funny on SNL. Worked one of his stand up shows. He was high as hell reading jokes off of his phone. -u/count_montecristo

12.
Carrot Top . And even more so when he got jacked. -u/Linsanity998877

13.
Steve Harvey. -u/isthreeinchesenough

14.
Chris D’Elia. Laughs at his own jokes, too. Ugh. -u/kellofkellens

15.
Bill Maher. Even when I agree with him, I just don't think he's clever or funny. -u/the_murder_of_crowe

16.
I love classic Chevy, but his whole career has been one-note. -u/fotomoose

17.
Dane Cook. -goldbrow00

18.
Gabriel Iglesias, I'm not sure why, he’s a great person and some people find him extremely hilarious, but I guess he's not for me. -u/tofimixy

19.
Aziz Ansari. I loved him in Parks and Rec. I didn’t enjoy his set when I saw him live and when I watched his specials. -u/d33jaysturf

20.
Jerry Seinfeld. -u/iwannahitthelotto